Wednesday, 12 October 2011

sample quiz essays

sample quiz essays

FAIR AND LOVELY ADVERTISEMENT

This advertisement represents the view of a somewhat superficial Pakistani society. By

portraying the fact that you must be fair to obtain success, (and not just any type of success, but

instant high grade success) they are passing the message along to the female youth of Pakistan

that they must lighten their skin and appear fairer than their competition. They are linking

fairness to beauty, which the commercial shows would ultimately result in inevitable success.

The profession chosen to show this triumph is that of show business, which further adds to the

superficiality of the society being represented. They could have chosen a more ‘worthwhile’

occupation to focus their advertisement on, such as a doctor or a businesswoman, but instead

they chose that line of work where women are expected to look good and attract attention to

themselves. This exemplifies the role of women as objects, to be looked upon and stared at by

the men in the society. Although the advertisement is pretty much absent of the opposite sex, it

still manages to portray the power that men have over the females in society, and shows the role

that women play in providing satisfaction to those very men in society.

Two classes of Pakistani society are represented here, that of the heroine and her mother who

belong to a middle/lower class, and that of the villainess who is from the higher/elite class. This

is clearly evident through the attire of the two women; the heroine is shown wearing simple,

worn out clothes, whereas the villainess is glimpsed sporting a more ‘glamorous’ ensemble.

Also, the heroine’s mother is shunned during the advertisement, where the villainess insults her

and tells her to go home and put makeup on her own daughter and daughter-in-laws. This is a

sign of her being shown her place-- behavior typical of that found in most upper middle class

homes where the maid/servant is subjected to similar verbal abuse. The commercial also shows a

modernist versus conservative comparison between the two women, where the heroine is the one

from an orthodox close knit family (shown again through the daughter-in-law comment) whereas

the villainess is portrayed as a more liberal, modern Pakistani woman.

The creators of the advertisement have employed the use of various techniques that help them

get their point of view across. For instance, when we first meet the villainess and the heroine’s

mother, and we see the latter being humiliated by the former, there is sad music playing in the

background. This is done purposefully and acts as a useful tool for generating sympathy from

the audience so that the viewer at once realizes who the ‘bad/good guy’ is in the story. Similarly,

when the heroine achieves success and her life is turning around, the melancholy music is

replaced by lively, upbeat music, done so as to create a feeling of happiness for the heroine in the

Specific camera angles are chosen so that the story is appreciated to the fullest. There is a close

up of the villainess’s face, which, according to John Fiske’s analysis in The Codes of Television,

is done so as to represent her ‘evilness’ as being ‘up in someone’s face’ is considered an invasion

of personal space as it portrays a threatening/hostile stance. Also, the heroine is given more

screen time, and plays more of a part in the overall story. We don’t get to hear the villainess’

side of the story at all, (perhaps she was having a bad day and that’s why she let out her anger on

the heroine’s mother?) and thus there is a biased point of view being presented. Also, since the

advertisement is for fairness creams, majority of the shots are those of the face.

The lighting in the heroine’s shots is dark initially. This, as well as the pounding rain, adds to

the gloomy, morose atmosphere being created. It also makes the villainess’s complexion appear

lighter than the heroine. But as the heroine emerges from her cocoon as a beautiful butterfly, she

seems to glow far brighter than the villainess. The lighting thus helps the audience focus all its

attention on this more ‘beautiful creature’.

The dialogues spoken by the heroine are chosen carefully so that the viewer feels sympathy

and affection towards her (seen through her emotional outburst in the beginning, and then by

her touching speech towards the end). The villainess on the other hand gets the dialogues that

generate negative feelings by the audience (seen when she shuns the old woman).

It is also interesting to note that when the heroine was a nobody, she was shown wearing a

simple shalwar qameez with a dupatta. But when she achieved success, her Pakistani dress

disappeared, and she was shown wearing a western gown, whereas the villainess is shown

wearing shalwar qameez both times. In my opinion this shows the more modern Pakistani

woman, with the freedom to wear whatever she does and does not want (hence the discarded

dupatta). However, it also shows how heavily influenced the Pakistani people are by the West,

and the fact that being successful is now being associated with being more western.

The overall view being presented through this advertisement is that a fair complexion equals

beauty, and beauty equal success. However it also brings out the positive aspects of Pakistani

society, that they are modest, humble and don’t forget their roots, as well as the importance of

mothers in Pakistani culture. (The heroine’s acceptance speech illustrates all this.) Also, the

commercial makes an attempt to reduce the superficiality by trying to focus on inner beauty;

although they do say that using their fairness cream will help bring this out. (They must sell their

product too!) This is a rather feeble attempt though, and it does nothing to remove the stereotype

that in Pakistan, fair women are considered beautiful, successful and worth paying attention to.

2 comments:

  1. Analysis of ’Fair and Lovely’ Advertisement

    The advertisement is for a product named ‘Fair and lovely’ which is a skin whitening cream. The Ad shows the life of a girl who is unsuccessful. She is dark skinned and middle class girl. After applying the cream she becomes fair and beautiful. Her beauty helps her achieve fame and fortune. A detailed semiotic analysis reveals the meanings and connotations encoded in the Ad
    The ad seems to imply that fortune and success are related to beautiful women. This represents the stereotype present in our Pakistani society that fair skinned women are better than dark ones. It implies that talent, personality and individuality are only secondary to fair and glowing skin. It also presents discrimination on the basis of colour. After watching the ad you get the message that people with darker skin tone cannot be successful.
    A close look at the ad shows that before her transformation into a beauty queen, the girl is wearing mediocre clothes. They are not modern and are old fashioned. They add to the meaning that the girl is unsuccessful and unhappy with her life. After she applies the cream and becomes fair, her clothes also transform into modern ones. This shows her accomplishments and her happiness with herself.
    Both of the women, the villainess as well as the protagonist, are shown to be looking at themselves in the mirror. They are beautifying themselves. This represents them as commodities. They are the objects of the man’s stare. As Berger (1972) points it out that it enables the women to see themselves as ‘Bearer of her own image’. This shows that the woman is basically designed to flatter the man and therefore her beauty is for his eyes.
    The lighting, editing, camera work and music also help to add meaning to the message which the producers are trying to convey. First of all more screen time and dialogue is given to the protagonist instead of the vamp which instantly makes the viewer side with the protagonist. The viewer gets to have more time with the protagonist and hence his sympathy goes with her. There is also a great difference in the amount of time given to the protagonist before and after the change. They give a higher amount of time to her after her transformation to reinforce her success.
    In the beginning of the commercial dark lighting is used. It is also raining. The music used is also slow and sad. The whole setting therefore is to show that the girl is unsuccessful and depressed with her life. While after the radical change in her looks, the surroundings are also changed to light tones. The music and the song go from melancholic to joyous. This successfully conveys the meaning to the viewer that the fairness cream has helped to change the life of the girl. It has helped in boasting her self esteem and her status in the society.
    The ad shows a capitalist society which is bound and restricted by class and discrimination. Its target audience is young girls and women of Pakistani society who are not satisfied with their complexion. It has quite a large amount of people as its target due to the stereotype of having fair skin tone as a guarantee to success. The points above therefore explain how meanings are encoded within the commercial. It also shows how the producers succeed in passing along the implied narrative under the cover of apparent meaning.
    References:-
    Berger, J. (1972) Ways of Seeing. Harmandsworth: Penguin.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 'The Whats determining the Whos'
    What determines who is represented in media? Is it those who have the power to represent themselves, or those who truly deserve to be represented? No, it is those who will be most easily manipulated at the hands of the media into buying a specific product. This Fair and Lovely advertisement is a perfect example of that- it relates the story of a young woman, aspiring to be a star but lost in the realms of anonymity. However, one day a sudden revelation strikes her, and she uses Fair and Lovely to become beautiful, which in turn makes her the star that she desired to be. The girl belongs to a decisively middle class background, with middle-class values (such as her taking lunch to her mother’s workplace) depicted in the ad, which makes it obvious who the target audience is. Had the latter been industrialists and their families, the ad would have shown both mother and daughter getting together for lunch at some expensive restaurant. But alas, that is not the case. A major problem of representation in this Pakistani ad is that even though it portrays reality, to which the audience can relate, it fails to show all of it. This ad takes into account young girls’ desire to become fair; Pakistani society’s misperception that only fair girls can succeed, the patriarchal element that dominates the film industry; but it does not show the poverty-stricken slums in Pakistan or the shiny cars that adorn rich families’ homes. This advertisement only covers a specific sphere of reality, which is its limitation.
    The advertisement begins in a very dramatic manner, with a girl taking lunch to her mother at work, who in turn is being mistreated there. The music that follows is soft and soothing, a melody that the audience will love and remember (the latter being important because it improves the product’s sales). The camera alternates between close-ups and distant shots to make sure both the protagonist and the setting come into light. An interesting fact is that when the revelation of using Fair and Lovely strikes the girl, she is sitting before a mirror, and the camera records her through the mirror, not directly. Thus, the mirror could symbolically be the stereotypes of Pakistani society through which the latter views young women, or the insecurities of young girls which lead them to believe becoming fair will also bring them luck and talent overnight; insecurities that stop them from truly appreciating themselves for who they are. Furthermore, twice in the ad a male voice calls out “shot ready” and “good shot”, while even the panel before which the girl models after her transformation is all male, which shows the male domination in Pakistani society, if not just in the media industry.
    Lastly, the advertisement also uses statements like “makeup tou nikal jaata hai, fairness saath rehti hai”(makeup is temporary, but fairness is eternal) and “naam/shohrat tou nikal jaate hain, maa saath rehti hain”(name and fame are not guaranteed to stay, but a mother is) to endorse Fair and Lovely’s logo of “Fair and Lovely….. Khoobsurti Hamesha”(Fair and Lovely…. eternal beauty). It is worth noting that a comparison is made between temporary elements and lasting ones: where makeup is the same as fame and fortune; easy come, easy go; while fairness granted by Fair and Lovely always stays with the person, like a mother’s loving presence. This advertisement is an excellent example of how media in Pakistan are capable of portraying aspects of society just as they are- but only certain ones, and those too to further their product. It fails to take into account other realities, since they are of no use in the marketing strategy devised by its experts, and this is something that definitely needs to change….. for the better!

    Amna Chandna

    ReplyDelete